I would love to have something outside the box...as long as its intuitive. I agree that I've never seen forums done pleasantly and intuitively; it seems you can only have one and not the other. I have much more control over how these forums operate (as opposed to the old MacScene, phpBB-based forums); since it's based on Kunena and heavily modified by...well...myself.
I haven't heard any complaints about the overall color scheme of the site, which honestly surprises me...I am not a designer. I also haven't really heard from anyone who has been in charge of the site over the past few months (I held the MacScene.net domain and had done the coding two years ago, IUG was paying for the hosting, iBatman was doing the posting, erise, shiggy, and Em seemed to be doing a lot of posting). I hate to feel I'm highjacking the site from whoever has been most active.
If you're interested in putting together a static proof of any ideas you might have, I'm happy to code it myself and see how it works. There's actually only a few pages needed for the forums (forum index, category threads, individual threads, Post New Topic, Reply, and a couple others). I'm happy to use any javascript and any 'Web 2.0' technologies (I'm a coder in the 'screw IE 6.0' camp). Let me know your thoughts. Thanks.